It’s that time of year again. The air gets a little crisper and every café in town rolls out the most coveted drink of the season—the Pumpkin Spice Latte.

Whether you love it or hate it, those three little letters—PSL—scream fall is here. The moment Starbucks drops it, people lose their minds. (Remember the lines wrapped around the building back in August? So wild what people will do for that first sip of fall.)

​Now imagine if your brand had that same pull.

​What if people were literally counting down the days for your next drop? Obsessing over your posts, products, or services like their next fall-flavored caffeine fix? It’s not an accident that the PSL became a cultural icon—it’s all about strategic branding.​

And guess what? You can totally apply the same moves to your business to create that crave-worthy obsession. Here’s how:

1. Consistency is Key: Be the PSL All Year Long

One of the reasons the Pumpkin Spice Latte is so successful is because it shows up consistently. Every fall, without fail, people are lining up to get their hands on one.

When it comes to your brand, consistency is everything. Your audience needs to know they can rely on you to show up regularly with valuable content, products, or services. Whether it’s through weekly blog posts, monthly newsletters, or a consistent social media schedule, you need to keep your brand top-of-mind all year long.

2. Build an Emotional Connection with Your Audience

Why do people love PSLs? It’s not just about the flavor (although, let’s be real, it’s delish). It’s about the feeling it gives them. PSLs are cozy, nostalgic, and give off serious “main character energy” as they stroll down a tree-lined street in their chunky scarves. It’s a full-on experience.

Your brand should make your audience feel something, too. Whether that’s empowerment, relief, excitement, or even a little FOMO (the good kind), tap into those emotions. It’s not just about selling a service; it’s about creating an experience your audience can’t get enough of. If they aren’t emotionally connecting with your brand, they’re scrolling right past you like a summer drink special in October.

To build an iconic brand, you need to create that same emotional connection with your audience. What does your brand make people feel? Empowered? Inspired? Relieved? Dig into the emotions behind what you offer and make sure those feelings come across in your messaging and branding.

3. Own Your Unique Flavor (Even If It’s Polarizing)

Not everyone loves Pumpkin Spice Lattes—gasp. And you know what? Starbucks doesn’t care. They embrace their uniqueness and know their loyal fans will show up in droves.

Your brand should do the same. You’re not for everyone, and that’s a good thing. The more you lean into what makes you different, the more you’ll attract the clients who are obsessed with what you offer. So be bold, own your uniqueness, and don’t be afraid to be polarizing. It’s better to be loved by some than ignored by all.

4. Create Anticipation and Hype for Your Brand

There’s no PSL without the hype. Weeks before its release, Starbucks teases it on social media, and people start counting down the days.

You can create that same anticipation for your brand by building hype for your next product, service, or content drop. Tease it on social media, send out sneak peeks to your email list, and get your audience excited to see what’s coming next. When people feel like they’re missing out, they’ll be first in line when you launch.

5. Be Unapologetically YOU (Like, Seriously, Lean In)

The Pumpkin Spice Latte isn’t trying to be something it’s not. It’s unapologetically spicy, sweet, and extra. Your brand needs to be the same. The more authentic and real you are, the more memorable your brand will be.

So ditch the imposter syndrome and embrace what makes your brand you. Because the more you lean into your true self, the more iconic you become—and the more your dream clients will be lining up for what only YOU can offer.

6. Build a Cult Following for Your Brand

The PSL has its own fandom—people who practically live for pumpkin spice season. These folks don’t just drink the latte; they wear the merch, post the pics, and tell everyone they know about their obsession. Your brand can have that same level of loyalty if you nurture your audience and give them reasons to keep coming back.

Reward your loyal clients, give them a behind-the-scenes look at your process, or offer exclusive deals. Make your audience feel like they’re part of something special, and they’ll become your biggest brand ambassadors.

Final Sip:

The Pumpkin Spice Latte didn’t become an icon by accident. It’s consistent, emotionally connected, and knows exactly what it brings to the table. If you want your brand to have the same recognition and loyalty, it’s time to brew up your own unique flavor and serve it with confidence.

So, how are you going to become the PSL of your industry? Are you ready to create a brand that people obsess over, crave, and can’t wait to experience? It’s time to step up and start brewing your brand’s next big move.

Looking for more actionable marketing insights?

Subscribe to The Content Pour-Over, a weekly newsletter that offers marketing insights every Wednesday morning. Enhance your content with buyer psychology and brand strategy principles.